How to control bacterial spot on tomatoes

Bacillus velezensis strain demonstrates important characteristics as an alternative for controlling bacterial spot in tomato

28.12.2020 | 20:59 (UTC -3)
Cultivar Hortaliças e Frutas

The tomato plant (Solanum lycopersicum) is one of the most important commercial vegetable crops, standing out among the cultivated solanaceae. However, many phytosanitary problems affect the crop, causing considerable losses. One of the main tomato diseases is bacterial spot, which affects all organs of the aerial part of the plant and, when in high severity, compromises the photosynthetic area, in addition to causing a reduction in the quantity and quality of the fruits. Until the beginning of this century, the disease was attributed to two causal agents: Xanthomonas vesicatoria e X. axonopodis p.v. vesicatory. Later, in 2004, through studies involving molecular biology tools, it was found that four species caused this disease, with subtle epidemiological and symptomatological differences between them. Although they all occur on tomato plants in Brazil, the species X. perforans it is considered prevalent in the main production areas.

Although there are different breeds of X. perforans, which increases the chances of success in controlling the disease through genetic resistance in tomato plants, other alternatives associated with disease management are important to help improved genotypes present durable resistance, in addition to serving other cultivars that are not resistant to bacterial spot. Although some pesticides are registered for their control, with an emphasis on copper, data demonstrate that their frequent use leads to the selection of resistant strains of the pathogen, causing them to lose their effectiveness. In this context, offering other options is important to compose a list of alternatives to integrate the bacterial spot control strategy.

The use of biological assets is an interesting option as a component of integrated disease management. Its demand is growing and it serves different production models, ranging from small and medium-sized properties, with gradual adoption by large ones. It also adds as advantages the reduction of the environmental and social impact of agricultural activities, an aspect increasingly demanded by society. These factors cause the natural pesticides market to grow more every year.

However, the biological control of plant bacterioses is a challenge, mainly due to the great versatility of bacterial pathogens. Among the strategies for controlling bacterioses using microbial active ingredients, some are more studied, such as the use of resistance induction mediated by rhizobacteria. However, these agents can also act in other ways, allowing us to explore aspects related to their important ecological characteristics of establishment and survival. It is possible to highlight, for example, the dispute for niches, which involves not only the competition for fundamental resources for their establishment, but also for the production of inhibitory compounds capable of assisting in their occupation.

In principle, a biological control agent that competes with the causal agent of a disease is promising. Imagine a newly sown seed. When germinating, both the root system and the aerial part in the process of emergence come into contact with microorganisms in the soil. Of these, those capable of using and benefiting from root exudates will compete for occupation of the area around the roots (rhizosphere), since in this location the plant will conveniently provide them with a source of nutrients. The same occurs in the occupation of the surface of the leaves (phylloplane). As the plant develops, these populations of microorganisms become established. Therefore, those who are best able to compete for exudates will have a greater chance of prevailing, to the detriment of others. In this process, the production of compounds that are inhibitory to other organisms is another ability that brings them advantages. This same principle can be applied to biological control agents, since using the modes of action involved in the dispute between a beneficial organism and a pathogen is an inherent foundation of biological control.

Additionally, a biocontrol agent that has characteristics that allow it to resist adverse environmental factors is also an advantage. These aspects make bacteria of the genus Bacillus and related genera gain special attention, both for their versatility and their ability to produce resistance spores, which give them the ability to survive in the face of adverse factors.

Symptoms of bacterial spot on a plant with roots not colonized by the biocontrol agent (control)
Symptoms of bacterial spot on a plant with roots not colonized by the biocontrol agent (control)

Collaborative research

Given these fundamentals, recent collaborative research between Embrapa, IF Goiano and Laboratório Farroupilha, involving these bacteria, postulated that the more mechanisms this control agent exerts, the greater its chances of achieving a good result in reducing the intensity of bacterial spot on the tomato. Furthermore, it sought to answer the question: What modes of action does the microorganism have to use to control this disease?

In this study, an isolate of Bacillus provided these answers. After standing out among other pre-selected bacteria, a strain of Bacillus velezensis demonstrated that some characteristics are in fact important for a microbial active to be able to control bacterial stain. The first of these was the ability to compete for resources with the pathogen. It was observed that both the B. velezensis as for X. perforans They are able to metabolize, to a large extent, the same sources of sugars and nitrogenous compounds. This indicates that, when the two bacteria are competing for the same space, they will compete for the same resources to establish themselves. In theory, whoever manages to establish themselves first will be able to occupy a certain niche, disadvantaging whoever arrives later. A second aspect observed was that B. velezensis produces inhibitory compounds X. perforans. When grown together, B. velezensis showed the ability to inactivate blood cells X. perforans five hours after the moment the same substrate was added. After this period together, the cells of X. perforans When placed to grow, they failed to generate colonies. This indicates that the biological control agent produces a substance capable of quickly killing pathogen cells. Therefore, where the biological control agent is established, the niche becomes quite unfavorable for X. perforans. These two properties explain how B. velezensis acts to control the disease, directly in the aerial part of the plant. That is, in those places where B. velezensis is established, X. perforans it has difficulty surviving on the plant surface before causing infection, resulting in minor damage to the plant. Even though X. perforans manages to cause infection in some locations, the presence of the antagonist could interfere with the viability of the inoculum source that would be dispersed to start new cycles of the disease, reducing damage.

Another form of action observed was the ability to induce resistance. When present on the roots of tomato plants, the disease took longer to be observed on the leaves and the damage was less while its effect remained active. Tests with enzymes related to the resistance induction response showed that at least two of them, peroxidase and polyphenoloxidase, were related to the ability to control the disease. This mode of control has the advantage of the bioagent's ability to trigger a systemic defense response in the plant. This makes it contribute to the control of the disease in different parts of the plant, even without its presence in the infection sites.

Therefore, it can be considered that this strain of B. velezensis can act both directly and indirectly in controlling bacterial spot. When in leaves, competing and inhibiting the establishment of X. perforans. When in the roots, activating the plant's own resistance response. This versatility of modes of action with which this control agent acts makes it an interesting biological asset in the control of bacteriosis. Added to this is its characteristic of producing resistant spores, which allows this microorganism to establish itself more easily in the tomato plant, in addition to increasing its viability and shelf life as a formulated product.

Symptoms of bacterial spot on a plant with its roots colonized by the biocontrol agent (Bacillus velezensis)
Symptoms of bacterial spot on a plant with its roots colonized by the biocontrol agent (Bacillus velezensis)

The closing thought

The modes of action employed by B. velezensis in the control of bacterial spot shed light on the attributes that are important for a microorganism to interfere with an aerial bacterial pathogen, resulting in reduced damage to plants. Understanding how they work is fundamental, both to define the best way to use them and to prospect for new bioactives. Exploring the aspects inherent to both the biocontrol agent and the pathogen is a key factor when searching for biological assets. Conducting some field studies involving, for example, the frequency of application and the concentration of viable cells to be used in formulation is still a step to be taken to offer this technology for use, in fact, by the farmer. However, the results found so far allow us to show how important it is to understand how a beneficial organism acts to the detriment of a harmful one and that a greater number of action mechanisms involved can result in greater effectiveness of the control agent.

Bernardo de Almeida Halfeld-Vieira, Embrapa Environment

Growing Vegetables and Fruits December/January 2021

With each new edition, Cultivar Hortaliças e Frutas publishes a series of technical content produced by renowned researchers from all over Brazil, which address the main difficulties and challenges encountered in the field by rural producers. Through research focused on controlling the main pests and diseases in vegetable and fruit cultivation, the Magazine helps farmers in the search for management solutions that increase their profitability. 

chip

Cultivar Newsletter

Receive the latest agriculture news by email

access whatsapp group
Ascribe